Net Operating Loss Carryback: It Isn’t All Bad News

net operating loss carryback

When a company’s deductible expenses exceed its income, generally a net operating loss (NOL) occurs. If when filing your 2017 income tax return you found that your business had an NOL, there is an upside. The upside to this are the tax benefits, including net operating loss carryback. But beware, the 2018 tax reform bill (Tax Cuts and Jobs Act – TCJA) makes some significant changes to the tax treatment of NOLs.

Pre-TCJA law

Under pre-TCJA law, when a business incurs a loss, a net operating loss carryback can be applied for up to two years. From there, you can carry any remaining amount forward for up to 20 years. The net operating loss carryback can generate an immediate tax refund, boosting cash flow.

The business can, however, elect instead to carry the entire loss forward. If cash flow is strong, this may be more beneficial, such as if the business’s income increases substantially, pushing it into a higher tax bracket — or if tax rates increase. In both scenarios, the carry-forward can save more taxes than the net operating loss carryback because deductions are more powerful when higher tax rates apply.

But the TCJA has established a flat 21% tax rate for C corporation taxpayers beginning with the 2018 tax year, and the rate has no expiration date. So C corporations don’t have to worry about Congress pushing them into a higher tax bracket. This is unless Congress changes the corporate rates again.

Also keep in mind that the rules are more complex for pass-through entities, such as partnerships, S corporations and limited liability companies (if they elected partnership tax treatment). Each owner’s allocable share of the entity’s loss are passing through to the owners while also reporting on their personal returns. The tax benefit depends on each owner’s particular tax situation.

The TCJA changes

The changes the TCJA made to the tax treatment of NOLs generally aren’t favorable to taxpayers:

For NOLs arising in tax years ending after December 31, 2017, a qualifying NOL can’t be carried back at all. This may be especially detrimental to start-up businesses, which tend to generate NOLs in their early years and can greatly benefit from the cash-flow boost of a carried-back NOL. (On the plus side, the TCJA allows NOLs to be carried forward indefinitely, as opposed to the previous 20-year limit.)

For NOLs arising in tax years beginning after December 31, 2017, an NOL carry-forward generally can’t be used to shelter more than 80% of taxable income in the carry-forward year. (Under prior law, generally up to 100% could be sheltered.)

The differences between the effective dates for these changes may have been a mistake, and a technical correction might be made by Congress. Also be aware that, in the case of a pass through entity, owners’ tax benefits from the entity’s net loss might be further limited under the TCJA’s new “excess business loss” rules.

Complicated Rules Get More Complicated

NOLs can provide valuable tax benefits. The rules, however, will always complications, and the TCJA is complicating them further. Please contact us if you’d like more information on the Net Operating Loss rules. Our CPA experts can help you maximize the tax benefit of an NOL.

© 2018