Independent Contractor vs Employee: How Should You Handle Worker Classification?


Group of Employees and Independent ContractorsMany employers prefer to classify a worker as an independent contractor vs employee to lower costs. However, under such classification generally means having less control over a worker’s day-to-day activities. But the government is on the lookout for businesses that classify workers as independent contractors simply to reduce taxes or avoid their employee benefit obligations.

Why it Matters

When your business classifies a worker as an employee, you generally must withhold federal income tax. In addition, you must also withhold the employee’s share of Social Security and Medicare taxes from his or her wages. Your business must then pay the employer’s share of these taxes, pay federal unemployment tax, file federal payroll tax returns and follow other burdensome IRS and U.S. Department of Labor rules.

You may also have to pay state and local unemployment and workers’ compensation taxes and comply with more rules. Dealing with all this can cost a bundle each year.

On the other hand, with independent contractor status, you don’t have to worry about employment tax issues. You also don’t have to worry about employer provided health benefits, retirement plans and paid vacations. If you pay $600 or more to an independent contractor during the year, you must file a Form 1099-MISC with the IRS and send a copy to the worker to report what you paid. That’s basically the extent of your bureaucratic responsibilities.

But say you incorrectly treat a worker as an independent contractor, and the IRS decides the worker is actually an employee. In such a situation, your business could be assessed unpaid payroll tax penalties plus interest. You also could be liable for employee benefits that should have been provided but weren’t, including penalties under federal laws.

Filing an IRS Form

To find out which status your worker fits in the employee vs contractor criteria, you can file optional IRS Form SS-8. The SS-8 form is the, “Determination of Worker Status for Purposes of Federal Employment Taxes and Income Tax Withholding.” Then, the IRS will let you know how to classify a worker. However, be aware that the IRS has a history of classifying workers as employees rather than independent contractors!

Businesses should consult with us before filing Form SS-8 because it may alert the IRS that your business has worker classification issues. In turn, this can inadvertently trigger an employment tax audit.

It can be better to simply treat independent contractors so the relationships comply with the tax rules. Generally, this includes not controlling how the workers perform their duties. This ensures that you’re not the workers’ only customer, providing annual Forms 1099 and not treating the workers like employees.

Workers Can Also Ask For A Determination

Workers who want an official determination of their status can also file Form SS-8. Disgruntled independent contractors may do so because they feel entitled to employee benefits and want to eliminate self employment tax.

If a worker files Form SS-8, the IRS will send a letter to the business. It identifies the worker and includes a blank Form SS-8. The IRS will ask the business to complete and return the form, which will render a classification decision.

Independent Contractor vs Employee: Defending Your Position

If your business properly handles independent contractors, don’t panic if a worker files a Form SS-8. Contact our Milwaukee CPA firm before replying to the IRS. With a proper response, you may be able to continue to classify the worker as a independent contractor vs employee. We also can assist you in setting up independent contractor relationships that stand up to IRS scrutiny.